From express wagons to the purple card: how a promise became America’s wallet.
This is the tenth profile in The Brand That…, a series about American brands that taught the country a habit, became the word for the thing itself, and outlived the world that made them. We tell their stories plainly and with respect — what they made, what it cost, and what they still are.
The Founding: Three Rivals in Buffalo
In March 1850 three men met in Buffalo and agreed to stop cutting one another’s throats.
Henry Wells ran express wagons between New York and Buffalo. William Fargo ran them west from Buffalo toward Cincinnati, Chicago, and St. Louis. John Butterfield ran against them both, and the rate wars bled all three.
On March 18 they signed Articles of Association, merged their firms, capitalized the venture at $150,000, and called it the American Express Company. Wells took the presidency. Fargo kept the books.
The business was carrying what the mail would not. In 1850 the Post Office would take nothing larger than a letter, and the country had grown larger than its letters. Gold coin, bank notes, contracts, oysters packed in ice, a fiddle bound for Peoria — the express wagon carried it and answered for it if it was lost. Buffalo was the right town for it, the hinge where the canal met the lakes and the new rails ran west; the city’s own story is told in the companion series, in The City That the Water Built. American Express owned no railroad and no steamboat; it bought space on other men’s lines. What it owned was the promise.
The peace did not hold. In 1852 Wells and Fargo wanted to follow the gold to California; Butterfield and the directors voted them down, so the two founded a second company under their own names. Wells Fargo went west, American Express held the East, and the two firms have been tangled in the country’s financial history ever since.
The Rise: Paper That Kept Its Word
When William Fargo died in 1881, his younger brother James took the company and ran it thirty-three years, hard, the way a man runs a thing he does not intend to lose. He came home from Europe with letters of credit nearly useless outside the great cities and told an employee named Marcellus Berry to fix it. Berry had fixed money once already. In 1882 he had designed the American Express Money Order, a form that could not be altered as a postal order could; the company sold 250,000 the first year. In 1891 Berry answered Fargo with the Travelers Cheque, and its ritual was simple: sign once when you buy it, sign again when you spend it, and if the two hands match, the paper is money. If it was lost or stolen, American Express made it good.
That was the habit the brand taught.
An American could now cross an ocean carrying paper instead of gold. Travelers learned to walk to the American Express office in Paris or London the way they might walk to an embassy — to change money, collect their mail, stand a minute inside something familiar. Within a decade the company sold more than six million dollars of cheques a year. And underneath ran a quieter engine: the float. Money paid for a cheque stayed with the company until it was cashed, and millions of other people’s dollars, resting and earning, turned a freight house into a financial house without anyone announcing the change.
The Turn: The Business Taken, the Card Given
The government took the founding business away in 1918. The railroads were nationalized for the war, and Washington folded every express operation into a single wartime carrier. Sixty-eight years after the wagons of Buffalo, American Express was no longer an express company at all. What remained was the paper — the cheques, the money orders, the travel offices — and the name. A decade later it nearly lost the name too: by 1929 Chase National Bank had quietly gathered ninety-seven percent of the shares, and only a stubborn remnant of holdouts — and later the Glass-Steagall wall — kept American Express its own house.
The answer to the Turn arrived on October 1, 1958, and it was small and it was purple.
The first card was paperboard, flimsy as a train ticket, dyed purple deliberately to match the Travelers Cheque — so that when a man laid it on a hotel desk, the color itself said the old promise held. It is worth sitting with that purple a moment: a company with a century of equity in a single shade of trust printed its future in the color of its past.
A quarter of a million people carried it at launch, 17,500 establishments honored it, and in May 1959 the paperboard became plastic, the first plastic card from a major issuer. Within five years a million people carried one. The middle class learned another rhythm: dine now, fly now, sign now, settle in full at the month’s end. The card was not quite credit; it was standing.
The Reckoning: Seawater in the Tanks
In November 1963 the company nearly died of its own signature. A subsidiary, American Express Warehousing, certified vegetable-oil inventories at Bayonne, New Jersey, for a commodities man named Anthony “Tino” De Angelis and issued receipts Wall Street took as collateral.
The tanks held mostly seawater. Oil floats, and a thin skin of salad oil lay over the water where the inspectors measured. Some tanks hid chambers beneath the measuring hatches; some were plumbed together so the same oil could travel ahead of the auditors. By the end Allied Crude claimed more oil than existed in the country. When it broke — the same week the President was killed in Dallas — the fraud ran to some $180 million across fifty-one lenders, the subsidiary collapsed under $210 million in claims, and American Express stock lost more than a third of its value.
The concession has to be made in full. The company earned this. Its entire business was verification — its name on a paper meant someone had looked — and for years its people collected fees certifying oil no one had honestly measured. A sounding rod pushed below the surface would have struck water. The trust company failed at the one thing trust requires, and the lenders who took its receipts at face value lost real money for believing the name.
Then the company did the thing it is remembered for. On November 27, 1963, president Howard Clark announced that though the parent might owe nothing at law, American Express felt “morally bound to do everything it can” to see the obligations satisfied. His own shareholders sued to stop him from giving away $60 million the company did not legally owe.
On the other side of their fear stood a young man in Omaha named Warren Buffett, who put roughly $13 million — in time about forty percent of everything he ran — into a five percent stake.
Why did the company live?
I have turned the record over and it will not settle. Perhaps it was Clark’s pledge, which turned a fraud into a proof of character. Perhaps it was Buffett’s money steadying the shares and his voice pushing the settlement through. Or perhaps the customers had already decided: Cheque sales rose twelve percent in 1964, in the teeth of the scandal — the public judged the name good before the company finished proving it. Likely all three braided together; no one can now say which strand bore the weight.
The standing the card conferred was never offered to everyone. Through most of the card’s first decades a woman could rarely get one in her own name; the husband’s signature governed, and the law did not forbid the practice until the Equal Credit Opportunity Act of 1974. The exclusivity was real, and part of what made it exclusive was who was kept out.
What Endures: The Closed Loop and the Long Echo
The company wandered once more, into the financial-supermarket 1980s — Shearson, then Lehman — until in the 1990s, under Harvey Golub, it sold and spun them away and went back to the card.
It has stayed there. American Express today runs a closed loop — issuing the card, signing the merchant, clearing the charge — a discipline its larger rivals do not attempt, and in 2025 it billed $1.67 trillion across the network.
Berkshire Hathaway, the long echo of 1964, holds roughly twenty-two percent. The Travelers Cheque was retired at the end of 2020, its work finished by the card it once colored.
In 1975 Karl Malden told the country, “Don’t leave home without them,” and in 1983 it coined “cause-related marketing,” pledging a penny per charge to restore the Statue of Liberty and raising $1.7 million — the old instinct, lashing the name to the country’s trust, still working.
Somewhere in the company’s New York archive the Articles of Association survive, three rivals’ signatures on one Buffalo agreement. The wagons are gone, the canal trade with them, and Bayonne is a lesson taught in business schools.
What endures is what the wagons truly carried, which was never only the gold: it was the answered promise — the money order that could not be forged, the cheque made good in a far city, the purple card laid on a hotel desk, the settlement paid when no court demanded it. A hundred and seventy-six years on, the name still does the oldest work it knows. It answers for what it carries.
American Express carried America’s wallet across the world, and that is worth remembering.
Why American Express? Because for a century the name was how an ordinary American moved money he could not afford to lose — the money order, the Cheque, the card — and because the deeper advantage was never the paper but the promise behind it, kept even in 1963, when keeping it cost $60 million the company did not legally owe.
* * * * *
Charles C. Jett is an author, civic educator, and Professional Certified Coach based in Chicago. A graduate of the U.S. Naval Academy (Class of 1964) and Harvard Business School, he served during the Cold War aboard the nuclear submarine USS Ray (SSN 653), where his tactical innovations helped inspire Tom Clancy’s Jack Ryan character. He is the author of six books, including Super Nuke!, hosts four podcasts, and writes across his Critical Skills Blog platform on history, leadership, and the health of the American republic. In his writing he employs AI tools in a limited, supporting role for research, occasional image creation, and editing, while the prose and judgment remain entirely his own. He and his wife, Dr. Nancy Church, live and co-host the Chicago Salons at Water Tower Residences.
Leave a Reply