The man who forced the Bill of Rights into existence never got credit for it. He died a year after it passed.
This is the next installment of Courage and Consequence — a series about relatively unknown individuals in history who made courageous decisions under extraordinary pressure, and had to live with what followed.
The Person
He did not want to go to Philadelphia.
George Mason was sixty-one years old in the spring of 1787, plagued by gout, and deeply committed to a life at Gunston Hall — his 5,500-acre Potomac estate where he supervised tenant farmers, managed his holdings, and read law from the library his uncle had left him.
He had turned down appointments to the Continental Congress. He had avoided the national stage for a decade. He called his preference “the happiness of independence and a private station.” He meant it.
He was not an obscure man. In Virginia, he was regarded as the finest constitutional mind of his generation. Jefferson called him “a man of the first order of greatness.” An Italian physician visiting Williamsburg in 1773 declared him a genius comparable to Dante or Galileo. His neighbors knew him as the man who, in May 1776, had walked into a drafting committee at the Fifth Virginia Convention and produced, in a matter of days, a document that would change the world: the Virginia Declaration of Rights — the first modern bill of rights appended to a written constitution, and the direct antecedent of both the Declaration of Independence and what would become the U.S. Bill of Rights.
He came to Philadelphia because Washington asked him. That was the only reason that worked.
The Context
The Constitutional Convention opened in May 1787 with a mandate to patch the Articles of Confederation. It quickly became something larger and more dangerous. The delegates were not patching anything. They were building a new national government from scratch.
Mason arrived as a supporter of constitutional reform. He understood the problem and intended to help solve it. He spoke 136 times by Madison’s count — among the highest of any delegate. He served on committees. He helped engineer the Great Compromise: equal state representation in the Senate, proportional in the House.
He was not a spectator. He was a builder.
Then came August, and the deal that broke him.
New England delegates wanted the foreign slave trade protected. South Carolina wanted favorable terms on navigation acts. They traded. The slave trade would continue until 1808. Mason’s insistence on a two-thirds majority for navigation acts — which would have protected Virginia tobacco shipping — was dropped in exchange.
Mason owned enslaved people. Likely as many as ninety at Gunston Hall. He would free none of them in his will. This is not a comfortable fact, and there is no way to make it comfortable.
But Mason had spent years calling the institution what it was. At the Convention he declared that “every master of slaves is born a petty tyrant.” He had written that slavery was “a slow poison, which is daily contaminating the minds and morals of our people.” He believed Providence would punish the nation for it: “As nations cannot be rewarded or punished in the next world, they must be in this.”
The 1808 deal was not an abstraction to him. It was a moral catastrophe built into the foundation of the document he had helped design.
“I would sooner chop off my right hand than put it to the Constitution as it now stands.” — George Mason, August 31, 1787
The Decision
September 12, 1787. Five days before the Convention ended.
Mason rose and moved that the Constitution be prefaced by a Bill of Rights. He argued it would take the committee only a few hours to draft one, using the existing state declarations as a model. He had written Virginia’s. He knew how.
The motion was defeated. Unanimously. Every state delegation voted no.
Mason could have signed anyway. Elbridge Gerry’s objections were those of a mercurial man; Edmund Randolph was calculating what ratification would do for his political future. Mason was the only one of the three who refused entirely on principle. He had spoken 136 times in four months of debate, shaped the document’s architecture, and helped rescue the Convention when it was close to collapse. He had earned the right to sign.
He walked out instead.
On the back of his Convention copy of the Committee of Style report, he wrote a document he titled Objections to This Constitution of Government. Sixteen items. Short. Specific. Devastating. Its opening line:
“There is no Declaration of Rights.”
He had not planned to publish it. It appeared in print without his permission on November 22, 1787. Within weeks it was everywhere — reprinted in newspapers from Boston to Savannah, the foundational statement of Anti-Federalist opposition. His opening line became the movement’s most effective slogan.
He wrote to Washington on October 7: “A little moderation and temper at the end of the convention might have removed [my objections].” Washington did not respond with moderation or temper. He referred to Mason afterward as his “former friend.”
The two men never reconciled.
The Aftermath
Mason had spent thirty years as Washington’s neighbor. They had served together in the Virginia legislature. Washington had sought his counsel on law and governance for decades. The friendship ended in a single phrase, in a letter to a third party, in the fall of 1787.
It was not the only cost. Mason was so unpopular in Fairfax County — his own county, where he had lived his entire life — that he had to run in neighboring Stafford County to get a seat at Virginia’s ratifying convention. He led the Anti-Federalist bloc there alongside Patrick Henry. They lost, 89 to 79. Virginia ratified.
Mason doubted Congress would act on amendments. He was wrong. James Madison — his former ally, now his adversary, now something in between — had watched the ratification debates in state after state. He had seen Mason’s opening line used as a rallying cry. He had seen the public demand build until it was impossible to ignore.
Madison introduced the Bill of Rights to the First Congress in 1789. He shepherded it through. He made sure it passed.
The Bill of Rights was ratified on December 15, 1791. Mason died on October 7, 1792 — the same date he had written to Washington five years earlier, attaching his Objections.
He had won. He never lived to be told so.
The Meaning
Mason is not in the popular memory of the Founding the way Washington, Madison, and Hamilton are. The reasons are documented: he left few papers; American memory elevates the signers; he preferred privacy and got it, permanently; he died before the founding mythology fully formed around the men who had signed.
And yet every American who invokes freedom of speech, freedom of the press, the right to a fair trial, or the prohibition of cruel and unusual punishment is speaking Mason’s language.
He wrote those guarantees first — in Virginia, in 1776, before the nation existed. He demanded them again in Philadelphia, in 1787, in the Objections he wrote on the back of someone else’s document. Madison made them law. Mason made them necessary.
The Virginia Declaration of Rights preceded the Declaration of Independence by more than a month. Jefferson had it in hand when he wrote the immortal opening. Mason gave Jefferson the words. Jefferson made them famous. Mason went home to Gunston Hall.
He built the house. He refused to sign the deed. And in refusing — in insisting that a house without rights was not a house anyone should live in — he ensured that what was finally signed was worth having.
That is the judgment of history, even if history forgot to deliver it while he was alive to hear it.
– – – – – – –
Sources: George Mason, Objections to This Constitution of Government (1787), National Archives transcription; Virginia Declaration of Rights (June 12, 1776), Virginia Memory / Library of Virginia; James Madison, Notes of Debates in the Federal Convention of 1787; Mason letter to George Washington, October 7, 1787; Jeff Broadwater, George Mason: Forgotten Founder (University of North Carolina Press, 2006); John Ferling, A Leap in the Dark (Oxford University Press, 2003).
Next in this series: Elbridge Gerry — He Named Eleven Structural Dangers in Writing. History Proved Him Right on Most of Them.
Charles C. Jett is an executive coach, civic educator, and Professional Certified Coach (PCC) based in Chicago. He is the founder of criticalskillsblog.com and civicsage.com, and the author of six books, including Super Nuke! The Courage and Consequence series profiles men and women who acted on principle at personal cost — and changed the world.
Leave a Reply